Research output: Contribution to Journal/Magazine › Journal article › peer-review
Research output: Contribution to Journal/Magazine › Journal article › peer-review
}
TY - JOUR
T1 - Evidence against dust-mediated control of glacial-interglacial changes in atmospheric CO2.
AU - Maher, Barbara A.
AU - Dennis, P. F.
PY - 2001/5/10
Y1 - 2001/5/10
N2 - The �iron fertilisation� hypothesis suggests controversially that atmospheric CO2 has been influenced by transport of iron-containing dust to the ocean surface1-3. Experiments in the Southern Ocean show that productivity, and subsequent CO2 drawdown, are enhanced by iron additions4. A carbon cycle model (forced by large values of Southern Ocean dust flux) indicates productivity changes during past glacial times could have reduced atmospheric CO2 by ~40ppm 5. However, Southern Ocean dust flux is very low at present and was increased, but still low, during past glaciations. Thus, as for the equatorial Pacific 1, 6, 7, distally-supplied, upwelled iron may be more significant than local dust-borne iron. Hence, Northern, not Southern, hemisphere dust may drive Southern Ocean productivity8,9. Here, we examine the flux and timing of N. Atlantic dust inputs in relation to the Vostok climate record. For the penultimate glaciation, two N. Atlantic dust peaks occurred. At 155 ka, the Atlantic dust flux was 2500x that at Vostok10, but declined well before the onset of the Vostok CO2 rise. The second dust peak, at 130ka, substantially post-dated the CO2 rise. Thus, low Southern Ocean dust fluxes, and this mismatch between N. hemisphere dust peaks and Southern Ocean climate change, appear not to support the suggested role of dust-mediated iron fertilisation in the Southern Ocean at Termination II.
AB - The �iron fertilisation� hypothesis suggests controversially that atmospheric CO2 has been influenced by transport of iron-containing dust to the ocean surface1-3. Experiments in the Southern Ocean show that productivity, and subsequent CO2 drawdown, are enhanced by iron additions4. A carbon cycle model (forced by large values of Southern Ocean dust flux) indicates productivity changes during past glacial times could have reduced atmospheric CO2 by ~40ppm 5. However, Southern Ocean dust flux is very low at present and was increased, but still low, during past glaciations. Thus, as for the equatorial Pacific 1, 6, 7, distally-supplied, upwelled iron may be more significant than local dust-borne iron. Hence, Northern, not Southern, hemisphere dust may drive Southern Ocean productivity8,9. Here, we examine the flux and timing of N. Atlantic dust inputs in relation to the Vostok climate record. For the penultimate glaciation, two N. Atlantic dust peaks occurred. At 155 ka, the Atlantic dust flux was 2500x that at Vostok10, but declined well before the onset of the Vostok CO2 rise. The second dust peak, at 130ka, substantially post-dated the CO2 rise. Thus, low Southern Ocean dust fluxes, and this mismatch between N. hemisphere dust peaks and Southern Ocean climate change, appear not to support the suggested role of dust-mediated iron fertilisation in the Southern Ocean at Termination II.
KW - Dust
KW - iron fertilisation
KW - Southern Ocean
KW - Atlantic Ocean
KW - deep sea sediments
KW - Quaternary
KW - terminations
U2 - 10.1038/35075543
DO - 10.1038/35075543
M3 - Journal article
VL - 411
SP - 176
EP - 180
JO - Nature
JF - Nature
IS - 6834
ER -