Home > Research > Publications & Outputs > Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition ...

Links

Text available via DOI:

View graph of relations

Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articlepeer-review

Published

Standard

Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine. / Strode, Sarah A.; Wang, James S.; Manyin, Michael; Duncan, Bryan; Hossaini, Ryan; Keller, Christoph A.; Michel, Sylvia E.; White, James W. C.

In: Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, Vol. 20, 17.07.2020, p. 8405-8419.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articlepeer-review

Harvard

Strode, SA, Wang, JS, Manyin, M, Duncan, B, Hossaini, R, Keller, CA, Michel, SE & White, JWC 2020, 'Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine', Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, vol. 20, pp. 8405-8419. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-8405-2020

APA

Strode, S. A., Wang, J. S., Manyin, M., Duncan, B., Hossaini, R., Keller, C. A., Michel, S. E., & White, J. W. C. (2020). Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 20, 8405-8419. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-8405-2020

Vancouver

Strode SA, Wang JS, Manyin M, Duncan B, Hossaini R, Keller CA et al. Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics. 2020 Jul 17;20:8405-8419. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-8405-2020

Author

Strode, Sarah A. ; Wang, James S. ; Manyin, Michael ; Duncan, Bryan ; Hossaini, Ryan ; Keller, Christoph A. ; Michel, Sylvia E. ; White, James W. C. / Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine. In: Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics. 2020 ; Vol. 20. pp. 8405-8419.

Bibtex

@article{a90510e62faf49aaaf142154035b12db,
title = "Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine",
abstract = "The 13C isotopic ratio of methane, δ13C of CH4, provides additional constraints on the CH4 budget to complement the constraints from CH4 observations. The interpretation of δ13C observations is complicated, however, by uncertainties in the methane sink. The reaction of CH4 with Cl is highly fractionating, increasing the relative abundance of 13CH4, but there is currently no consensus on the strength of the tropospheric Cl sink. Global model simulations of halogen chemistry differ strongly from one another in terms of both the magnitude of tropospheric Cl and its geographic distribution. This study explores the impact of the intermodel diversity in Cl fields on the simulated δ13C of CH4. We use a set of GEOS global model simulations with different predicted Cl fields to test the sensitivity of the δ13C of CH4 to the diversity of Cl output from chemical transport models. We find that δ13C is highly sensitive to both the amount and geographic distribution of Cl. Simulations with Cl providing 0.28 % or 0.66 % of the total CH4 loss bracket the δ13C observations for a fixed set of emissions. Thus, even when Cl provides only a small fraction of the total CH4 loss and has a small impact on total CH4, it provides a strong lever on δ13C. Consequently, it is possible to achieve a good representation of total CH4 using widely different Cl concentrations, but the partitioning of the CH4 loss between the OH and Cl reactions leads to strong differences in isotopic composition depending on which model's Cl field is used. Comparing multiple simulations, we find that altering the tropospheric Cl field leads to approximately a 0.5 ‰ increase in δ13CH4 for each percent increase in how much CH4 is oxidized by Cl. The geographic distribution and seasonal cycle of Cl also impacts the hemispheric gradient and seasonal cycle of δ13C. The large effect of Cl on δ13C compared to total CH4 broadens the range of CH4 source mixtures that can be reconciled with δ13C observations. Stronger constraints on tropospheric Cl are necessary to improve estimates of CH4 sources from δ13C observations.",
author = "Strode, {Sarah A.} and Wang, {James S.} and Michael Manyin and Bryan Duncan and Ryan Hossaini and Keller, {Christoph A.} and Michel, {Sylvia E.} and White, {James W. C.}",
year = "2020",
month = jul,
day = "17",
doi = "10.5194/acp-20-8405-2020",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "8405--8419",
journal = "Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics ",
issn = "1680-7316",
publisher = "Copernicus GmbH (Copernicus Publications) on behalf of the European Geosciences Union (EGU)",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - Strong sensitivity of the isotopic composition of methane to the plausible range of tropospheric chlorine

AU - Strode, Sarah A.

AU - Wang, James S.

AU - Manyin, Michael

AU - Duncan, Bryan

AU - Hossaini, Ryan

AU - Keller, Christoph A.

AU - Michel, Sylvia E.

AU - White, James W. C.

PY - 2020/7/17

Y1 - 2020/7/17

N2 - The 13C isotopic ratio of methane, δ13C of CH4, provides additional constraints on the CH4 budget to complement the constraints from CH4 observations. The interpretation of δ13C observations is complicated, however, by uncertainties in the methane sink. The reaction of CH4 with Cl is highly fractionating, increasing the relative abundance of 13CH4, but there is currently no consensus on the strength of the tropospheric Cl sink. Global model simulations of halogen chemistry differ strongly from one another in terms of both the magnitude of tropospheric Cl and its geographic distribution. This study explores the impact of the intermodel diversity in Cl fields on the simulated δ13C of CH4. We use a set of GEOS global model simulations with different predicted Cl fields to test the sensitivity of the δ13C of CH4 to the diversity of Cl output from chemical transport models. We find that δ13C is highly sensitive to both the amount and geographic distribution of Cl. Simulations with Cl providing 0.28 % or 0.66 % of the total CH4 loss bracket the δ13C observations for a fixed set of emissions. Thus, even when Cl provides only a small fraction of the total CH4 loss and has a small impact on total CH4, it provides a strong lever on δ13C. Consequently, it is possible to achieve a good representation of total CH4 using widely different Cl concentrations, but the partitioning of the CH4 loss between the OH and Cl reactions leads to strong differences in isotopic composition depending on which model's Cl field is used. Comparing multiple simulations, we find that altering the tropospheric Cl field leads to approximately a 0.5 ‰ increase in δ13CH4 for each percent increase in how much CH4 is oxidized by Cl. The geographic distribution and seasonal cycle of Cl also impacts the hemispheric gradient and seasonal cycle of δ13C. The large effect of Cl on δ13C compared to total CH4 broadens the range of CH4 source mixtures that can be reconciled with δ13C observations. Stronger constraints on tropospheric Cl are necessary to improve estimates of CH4 sources from δ13C observations.

AB - The 13C isotopic ratio of methane, δ13C of CH4, provides additional constraints on the CH4 budget to complement the constraints from CH4 observations. The interpretation of δ13C observations is complicated, however, by uncertainties in the methane sink. The reaction of CH4 with Cl is highly fractionating, increasing the relative abundance of 13CH4, but there is currently no consensus on the strength of the tropospheric Cl sink. Global model simulations of halogen chemistry differ strongly from one another in terms of both the magnitude of tropospheric Cl and its geographic distribution. This study explores the impact of the intermodel diversity in Cl fields on the simulated δ13C of CH4. We use a set of GEOS global model simulations with different predicted Cl fields to test the sensitivity of the δ13C of CH4 to the diversity of Cl output from chemical transport models. We find that δ13C is highly sensitive to both the amount and geographic distribution of Cl. Simulations with Cl providing 0.28 % or 0.66 % of the total CH4 loss bracket the δ13C observations for a fixed set of emissions. Thus, even when Cl provides only a small fraction of the total CH4 loss and has a small impact on total CH4, it provides a strong lever on δ13C. Consequently, it is possible to achieve a good representation of total CH4 using widely different Cl concentrations, but the partitioning of the CH4 loss between the OH and Cl reactions leads to strong differences in isotopic composition depending on which model's Cl field is used. Comparing multiple simulations, we find that altering the tropospheric Cl field leads to approximately a 0.5 ‰ increase in δ13CH4 for each percent increase in how much CH4 is oxidized by Cl. The geographic distribution and seasonal cycle of Cl also impacts the hemispheric gradient and seasonal cycle of δ13C. The large effect of Cl on δ13C compared to total CH4 broadens the range of CH4 source mixtures that can be reconciled with δ13C observations. Stronger constraints on tropospheric Cl are necessary to improve estimates of CH4 sources from δ13C observations.

U2 - 10.5194/acp-20-8405-2020

DO - 10.5194/acp-20-8405-2020

M3 - Journal article

VL - 20

SP - 8405

EP - 8419

JO - Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics

JF - Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics

SN - 1680-7316

ER -