TY - JOUR

T1 - Wittgenstein at Ground Zero

AU - Sayer, Derek

PY - 2008/2

Y1 - 2008/2

N2 - Drawing on the work of Barthes and Wittgenstein, this article presents an argument for taking seriously the widespread sentiment, at the time, that the events of what we have since come to call “9-11” were unspeakable. Central to the article is an analysis of two sharply contrasting responses to the 9-11 events, the Here Is New York photographic exhibition and a symposium by prominent intellectuals in The London Review of Books. The widespread revulsion that greeted such intellectual attempts to make sense of 9-11, the article argues, is not evidence of sentiment clouding reason so much as a refusal to efface a profound otherness by assimilating it to the categories of our comprehension—much like Here Is New York's use of photographs to resist the translation of 9-11 into text.

AB - Drawing on the work of Barthes and Wittgenstein, this article presents an argument for taking seriously the widespread sentiment, at the time, that the events of what we have since come to call “9-11” were unspeakable. Central to the article is an analysis of two sharply contrasting responses to the 9-11 events, the Here Is New York photographic exhibition and a symposium by prominent intellectuals in The London Review of Books. The widespread revulsion that greeted such intellectual attempts to make sense of 9-11, the article argues, is not evidence of sentiment clouding reason so much as a refusal to efface a profound otherness by assimilating it to the categories of our comprehension—much like Here Is New York's use of photographs to resist the translation of 9-11 into text.

KW - language

KW - terrorism

KW - photography

U2 - 10.1177/1206331207310375

DO - 10.1177/1206331207310375

M3 - Journal article

VL - 11

SP - 12

EP - 19

JO - Space and Culture

JF - Space and Culture

SN - 1206-3312

IS - 1

ER -