Final published version, 3.64 MB, PDF document
Available under license: CC BY: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Research output: Thesis › Doctoral Thesis
Research output: Thesis › Doctoral Thesis
}
TY - BOOK
T1 - Policy interpreted
T2 - the effect of local authority administration and officer perception and practice on national home-education policy implementation
AU - Mukwamba-Sendall, Fe
PY - 2019
Y1 - 2019
N2 - Home-education is enshrined in State legislation and statutory guidance, which is administered by local authorities (LA) and implemented by their officers. Home-education engenders concern. Stakeholder critics allude to risks for children ranging from educational or psychological harm to physical neglect or abuse. Accusations, which lack evidenced based research, problematise home-education creating suspicion which impacts on LA administrator and officer implementer. This is observable in their beyond-legal authority practices. This research examines LA administration of State policy ‘strategies’ through Freedom of Information questionnaire responses and documentary evidence (webpages, literature, and officer job descriptions). Interviews examine influences on officer perceptions which impact on their implementation practices. Interviews with home-education advocates provide insight into outcomes of LA administration and officer implementation. The study is sited within Implementation Theory, specifically Street Level Bureaucrats, Lipsky, 1969, 1971, 1980, 2010; Implementation Staircase, Reynolds and Saunders, 1987; and Communities of Practice, Wenger, 1998, 2006, 2010. Conclusions are drawn through the adoption of a thematic analysis approach. There is a marked lack of homogeneity in the implementation of State policy at local level, with policies and practices varying between different local authorities and individual officers. There is discord in the opinions of stakeholder commentators, academics, professionals and EHE advocates regarding specific concerns of, educational suitability, registration, monitoring, visits, and safeguarding. State strategy becomes redefined resulting in hybrid local policies visible in LA administration and officer implementation practices which imply powers or legal authority that they do not have. Such changes constitute a degradation of State strategy. Locally adopted policy stimulates a precedent of practice, whereby intended State strategy becomes redefined during the delegated process of implementation.
AB - Home-education is enshrined in State legislation and statutory guidance, which is administered by local authorities (LA) and implemented by their officers. Home-education engenders concern. Stakeholder critics allude to risks for children ranging from educational or psychological harm to physical neglect or abuse. Accusations, which lack evidenced based research, problematise home-education creating suspicion which impacts on LA administrator and officer implementer. This is observable in their beyond-legal authority practices. This research examines LA administration of State policy ‘strategies’ through Freedom of Information questionnaire responses and documentary evidence (webpages, literature, and officer job descriptions). Interviews examine influences on officer perceptions which impact on their implementation practices. Interviews with home-education advocates provide insight into outcomes of LA administration and officer implementation. The study is sited within Implementation Theory, specifically Street Level Bureaucrats, Lipsky, 1969, 1971, 1980, 2010; Implementation Staircase, Reynolds and Saunders, 1987; and Communities of Practice, Wenger, 1998, 2006, 2010. Conclusions are drawn through the adoption of a thematic analysis approach. There is a marked lack of homogeneity in the implementation of State policy at local level, with policies and practices varying between different local authorities and individual officers. There is discord in the opinions of stakeholder commentators, academics, professionals and EHE advocates regarding specific concerns of, educational suitability, registration, monitoring, visits, and safeguarding. State strategy becomes redefined resulting in hybrid local policies visible in LA administration and officer implementation practices which imply powers or legal authority that they do not have. Such changes constitute a degradation of State strategy. Locally adopted policy stimulates a precedent of practice, whereby intended State strategy becomes redefined during the delegated process of implementation.
KW - Home education, home schooling, policy implementation, England
U2 - 10.17635/lancaster/thesis/602
DO - 10.17635/lancaster/thesis/602
M3 - Doctoral Thesis
PB - Lancaster University
ER -