Final published version, 1.54 MB, PDF document
Available under license: CC BY: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Research output: Working paper
Research output: Working paper
}
TY - UNPB
T1 - Decreasing Differences in Expert Advice
T2 - Evidence from Chess Players
AU - Bouacida, Elias
AU - Foucart, Renaud
AU - Jalloul, Maya
PY - 2024/2/12
Y1 - 2024/2/12
N2 - We study the impact of external advice on the relative performance of chessplayers. We asked players in chess tournaments to evaluate positions in past games and allowed them to revise their evaluation following advice from a high or a low ability player. While our data confirms the theoretical prediction that high-quality advice has the potential to act as a “great equalizer,” reducing the difference between high and low ability players, this is not what happens in practice. This is in part because our subjects ignore too much of the advice they receive, but also because low ability players pay – either due to overconfidence or intrinsic preference – a higher premium than high ability ones by following their initial idea instead of high-quality advice.
AB - We study the impact of external advice on the relative performance of chessplayers. We asked players in chess tournaments to evaluate positions in past games and allowed them to revise their evaluation following advice from a high or a low ability player. While our data confirms the theoretical prediction that high-quality advice has the potential to act as a “great equalizer,” reducing the difference between high and low ability players, this is not what happens in practice. This is in part because our subjects ignore too much of the advice they receive, but also because low ability players pay – either due to overconfidence or intrinsic preference – a higher premium than high ability ones by following their initial idea instead of high-quality advice.
KW - decreasing differences
KW - expert
KW - advice
KW - chess
KW - control
M3 - Working paper
T3 - Economics Working Papers Series
BT - Decreasing Differences in Expert Advice
PB - Lancaster University, Department of Economics
CY - Lancaster
ER -