TY - JOUR

T1 - Modelling nitrogen loads at the catchment scale under the influence of land use.

AU - Payraudeau, S.

AU - Cernesson, F.

AU - Tournoud, M. G.

AU - Beven, Keith J.

PY - 2004/1

Y1 - 2004/1

N2 - Land use data are essential for water quality models. Pollutant inputs to streams are indeed a direct function of human activities that can be represented, at least approximately, in terms of land use. Remote sensing is a valuable data source to determine the land use on a catchment. However the land use data obtained by this kind of information are subject to significant uncertainties, including misclassification or categorical uncertainty. This paper presents a method to analyse the impact of the land use categorical uncertainty on the responses of a nitrogen load model at the outlet of a catchment. We use the POL model, a semi-distributed event-based model on a French Mediterranean rural catchment and we focus on agricultural land use. First, the sensitivity analysis realised by simulations considering a uniform land use on the catchment, shows a great sensitivity of the estimated load to the land use change. Second, the categorical land use uncertainty is analysed on a total nitrogen load prediction set calculated with randomly generated land use maps consistent with the confusion matrix that characterizes misclassification of land use. Thus, from 1% to 10% of misclassified agricultural area results in a variation of almost 40% on nitrogen loads for the three studied events. Misclassified areas explain from 46% to 75% of the variance of the estimated nitrogen load. These first results illustrate the importance of sensitivity and uncertainty analyses to improve the confidence of a water quality model and need to be extended to other input data sets.

AB - Land use data are essential for water quality models. Pollutant inputs to streams are indeed a direct function of human activities that can be represented, at least approximately, in terms of land use. Remote sensing is a valuable data source to determine the land use on a catchment. However the land use data obtained by this kind of information are subject to significant uncertainties, including misclassification or categorical uncertainty. This paper presents a method to analyse the impact of the land use categorical uncertainty on the responses of a nitrogen load model at the outlet of a catchment. We use the POL model, a semi-distributed event-based model on a French Mediterranean rural catchment and we focus on agricultural land use. First, the sensitivity analysis realised by simulations considering a uniform land use on the catchment, shows a great sensitivity of the estimated load to the land use change. Second, the categorical land use uncertainty is analysed on a total nitrogen load prediction set calculated with randomly generated land use maps consistent with the confusion matrix that characterizes misclassification of land use. Thus, from 1% to 10% of misclassified agricultural area results in a variation of almost 40% on nitrogen loads for the three studied events. Misclassified areas explain from 46% to 75% of the variance of the estimated nitrogen load. These first results illustrate the importance of sensitivity and uncertainty analyses to improve the confidence of a water quality model and need to be extended to other input data sets.

KW - Prediction uncertainty

KW - Model sensitivity

KW - Land use

KW - Water quality model

U2 - 10.1016/j.pce.2004.05.008

DO - 10.1016/j.pce.2004.05.008

M3 - Journal article

VL - 29

SP - 811

EP - 819

JO - Physics and Chemistry of the Earth

JF - Physics and Chemistry of the Earth

SN - 1474-7065

IS - 11-12

ER -