TY - JOUR

T1 - Testing open-source visualization tools with small- and medium-sized enterprises ecosystem data

T2 - Towards the understanding of innovation ecosystem design

AU - Nthubu, Badziili

AU - Richards, Daniel

AU - Cruickshank, Leon

N1 - © Nthubu, 2021. The definitive, peer reviewed and edited version of this article is published in Journal of Design, Business & Society, Volume 7, Number 2, 165-187, 2021, https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/intellect/dbs/2021/00000007/00000002/art00004

PY - 2021/10/1

Y1 - 2021/10/1

N2 - This paper explores open-source visualization tools using innovation ecosystem empirical data to enhance the understanding of SME ecosystem structures. Ecosystem approaches are becoming important in business strategy and innovation where organizations are heavily relying on inter-firm resources to innovate. Consequently, the traditional firm-focused business models are facing challenges, thus making it difficult for interconnected and diverse actors to figure out how to co-create across firm boundaries. This challenge is even worse for manufacturing SMEs, who often lack the tools to make sense of their innovation ecosystem structures. This present study involved a rich ethnographic investigation in three SME ecosystem cases in the UK, i.e. the ceramic artist ecosystem, the 3D printing bureau ecosystem and the FabLab ecosystem. From the initial thematic analysis results, all participants indicated the difficulty in understanding complexities associated with the dynamics of innovation ecosystem structures. The following ecosystem attributes were highlighted as essential in understanding SME innovation ecosystem structures; Clusters and bridges, tie size, structural holes, role structure, interactivity. In this paper, fourteen open-source visualization tools are tested to compare how well different methods reveal the six ecosystem attributes. Our findings demonstrate that open-source visualization tools have different affordances, most of which are useful in revealing ecosystem attributes. Results show that most tools reveal six attributes identified in this study as useful in aiding the understanding of SME ecosystem structures. This study contributes new knowledge on the scarce subject of designing and managing innovation ecosystems, presenting a unique design visualization approach to explore and understand ecosystem configurations. The study also identifies limitations in open-source visualization methods and offer the design management community a set of recommendations for further development of visualization tools to support decision making in manufacturing SME ecosystems.

AB - This paper explores open-source visualization tools using innovation ecosystem empirical data to enhance the understanding of SME ecosystem structures. Ecosystem approaches are becoming important in business strategy and innovation where organizations are heavily relying on inter-firm resources to innovate. Consequently, the traditional firm-focused business models are facing challenges, thus making it difficult for interconnected and diverse actors to figure out how to co-create across firm boundaries. This challenge is even worse for manufacturing SMEs, who often lack the tools to make sense of their innovation ecosystem structures. This present study involved a rich ethnographic investigation in three SME ecosystem cases in the UK, i.e. the ceramic artist ecosystem, the 3D printing bureau ecosystem and the FabLab ecosystem. From the initial thematic analysis results, all participants indicated the difficulty in understanding complexities associated with the dynamics of innovation ecosystem structures. The following ecosystem attributes were highlighted as essential in understanding SME innovation ecosystem structures; Clusters and bridges, tie size, structural holes, role structure, interactivity. In this paper, fourteen open-source visualization tools are tested to compare how well different methods reveal the six ecosystem attributes. Our findings demonstrate that open-source visualization tools have different affordances, most of which are useful in revealing ecosystem attributes. Results show that most tools reveal six attributes identified in this study as useful in aiding the understanding of SME ecosystem structures. This study contributes new knowledge on the scarce subject of designing and managing innovation ecosystems, presenting a unique design visualization approach to explore and understand ecosystem configurations. The study also identifies limitations in open-source visualization methods and offer the design management community a set of recommendations for further development of visualization tools to support decision making in manufacturing SME ecosystems.

U2 - 10.1386/dbs_00026_1

DO - 10.1386/dbs_00026_1

M3 - Journal article

VL - 7

SP - 165

EP - 187

JO - Journal of Design, Business & Society

JF - Journal of Design, Business & Society

SN - 2055-2114

IS - 2

ER -